A review of an expert opinion is a professional assessment of a forensic expert’s opinion by another qualified specialist. The reviewer checks compliance with procedural law, the correct application of expert methods, the logical validity of the conclusions and the completeness of the research. The result is issued as a specialist’s opinion, which is filed with the case materials and used to support a motion for a repeat or additional examination.
For foreign parties to Russian proceedings, a review is often the only effective way to challenge an expert opinion: a court will not take a general statement of disagreement into account, but it is obliged to assess a specialist’s opinion that lists specific violations with references to legal norms and methods.
- specialist’s opinion for the court
- all types of forensic examination
- timeframe from 5 working days
- free preliminary assessment
Legal basis
The specialist’s opinion is provided for in Russian procedural codes: Article 188 of the Civil Procedure Code, Article 58 and Part 3 of Article 80 of the Criminal Procedure Code, Article 87.1 of the Arbitration Procedure Code and Article 169 of the Code of Administrative Procedure of the Russian Federation. It is independent evidence in the case.
What we review
Psychiatric, psychological, linguistic, handwriting and technical document examinations, financial-economic and accounting examinations, valuation examinations, construction-technical and other types of forensic examination.
When a review is needed
- you disagree with the conclusions of the examination and believe the expert made mistakes;
- the conclusions contradict other evidence in the case;
- you need grounds for a motion for a repeat or additional examination;
- you are preparing to question the expert in court;
- the opposing party has submitted an out-of-court opinion and you need to assess its quality;
- a key procedural decision is based on the expert opinion and has to be challenged on appeal or in cassation.
Errors identified by a review
1. Procedural violations
The expert going beyond their competence, no signed warning of criminal liability (Article 307 of the Criminal Code), an examination by a person who should have been recused, violation of the parties’ rights, research on materials not provided by the court.
2. Methodological violations
Outdated, inappropriate or untested methods, skipped mandatory stages, an unjustified choice of method, calculation errors, misinterpretation of data, inconsistency between the research part and the conclusions.
3. Logic and completeness
Conclusions not supported by the research, internal contradictions, unanswered questions, selective use of data, substitution of expert conclusions with a legal assessment.
How the review works
- Materials. You send us a copy of the expert opinion and, if available, the court ruling ordering the examination and other relevant documents — in person, by post or electronically.
- Preliminary assessment — free of charge. Our specialist studies the opinion, assesses the prospects and determines the timeframe and cost.
- Review. A detailed analysis recording every error with references to specific norms and methodological requirements.
- Specialist’s opinion. A document in the established form listing the violations, references to regulations and conclusions on how they affect the reliability of the expert opinion.
What a review can lead to
- the court orders a repeat examination by another expert or institution;
- the court orders an additional examination on unanswered questions;
- the court summons the expert for questioning on the issues identified in the review;
- the court excludes the expert opinion from evidence if gross procedural violations are found.
Related services
Contact us
The initial consultation is free of charge. Send us a description of your situation or a copy of the documents, and we will advise on the type of examination, timeframe and cost.
- Phone: +7 495 414-20-63
- Email: post@use.moscow
- Address: office 221, building 13, 2 3rd Yamskogo Polya Street, Moscow 125124, Russia
- Office hours: Monday–Friday, 9:00–18:00 (Moscow time, UTC+3)
